The physics of the 2015 Supertide in Western Europe

Mont Saint Michel

The causes of tides

The tides are caused by two things.

  1. The moon’s gravitational force pulling on the oceans.
  2. The sun’s gravitational force pulling on the oceans.

An eclipse does not cause the tides. It did not cause the so-called Supertide that enveloped Mont Saint Michel and London’s river Thames yesterday. The newspapers are getting it wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong.

However, the eclipse and the supertide do have a common cause, which is a new moon. What’s a common cause? Yellow teeth and lung cancer have a common cause: smoking. No one would say that yellow teeth causes lung cancer, right? Well, no one should say that an eclipse caused the super tide for exactly the same reason. (Read more about this in my Lecture Notes on Causation.)

Here is how the moon creates tides: it pulls on the oceans, which cause them to slosh into an American football-shape that points at the moon. As the earth spins the peak of the football sloshes across different locations, causing a high tide roughly once per day.

The moon's effect on the tide

There is a stronger tide roughly twice per month, whenever the sun and the moon align, and in particular when there is a new moon.

Now, a new moon can cause a solar eclipse under much rarer circumstances, whenever the moon’s shadow happens to pass across your location. (For an explanation of why there isn’t an eclipse on every new moon, try this.) It is the monthly new moon, rather than the rare location of the shadow, is the cause of the tide — not the eclipse!

The physics of the supertide

What are the physics that gave rise to the supertide? There are two main factors.

First, there is an especially strong tide when the sun and the moon align and the moon is closer than normal to the earth. This location is called the Perigee, and the stronger tide is called a Perigean tide, occurring a few times a year.

Second, there is an especially strong tide when the sun and the moon align and the earth is closer than normal to the sun. This is called a Spring tide, and happens every Spring, but is strongest nearest to the Equinox.

If all three things happen at once, then one gets an especially strong tide called a Perigean Spring tide.

That is the real cause of the Supertide. It is because the earth, moon and sun looked like this:

Perigean Spring Tide

Here is the summary of what makes a tide stronger than normal.

  • Strong tide: New moon (sun and moon align — sometimes also causes eclipse)
  • Stronger tide: New moon + Perigee (Perigean tide)
  • Strongest tide: New moon + Perigee + Spring (Spring Perigean tide)

The Supertide was just a Spring Perigean tide that occurred the day before the equinox. That is the main reason that it was so strong. It is also possible that it was augmented by the effects of global wind.

In summary: the supertide in Western Europe was caused by the New Moon, Perigee and Spring tide occurring at once so close to the equinox. What is silly is that our friends over at the Daily Mail reported this occurrence, but still decided to report that the eclipse caused the high tides. The New Moon was also part of the cause of the eclipse. But the eclipse did not cause the supertide any more than yellow teeth cause lung cancer.

 

2 thoughts on “The physics of the 2015 Supertide in Western Europe

  1. Tom Ace

    You wrote: “Second, there is an especially strong tide when the sun and the moon align and the earth is closer than normal to the sun. This is called a Spring tide, and happens every Spring, but is strongest nearest to the Equinox.”

    Spring tide” refers only to the peak additive effect of solar and lunar tides seen twice a month (at new moon and full moon) and not to Earth’s perihelion. Despite its name, it is unrelated to the spring season.

    And, Earth’s perihelion currently happens in January which isn’t springtime in either hemisphere.

  2. Toly

    I would like to recommend the wonderful book: “Lucio Russo. Flussi e riflussi: indagine sull’origine di una teoria scientifica. Feltrinelli Editore, 2003” on the intriguing history of the theory of tides. Unfortunately it is only available in Italian (for the moment at least).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You can use standard LaTeX enclosed in dollar signs, e.g., $\sqrt{2}^2=2$ gets rendered as .
You can also use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>